A few of our stories and columns are now in front of the paywall. We at The Chief remain committed to independent reporting on labor and civil service. It's been our mission since 1897. You can have a hand in ensuring that our reporting remains relevant in the decades to come. Consider supporting The Chief, which you can do for as little as $3.20 a month.
To the editor:
Ron Isaac's May 22 column has the appropriate headline, "Blinded justice." In his excellent essay is an example of a judge who gave only a ninemonth sentence to a man who beat a homeless man to death.
Then there's the case of an NYPD sergeant who threw a water cooler at a suspect fleeing on a motorized scooter. This unintentionally caused the suspect's death.
The same judge sentenced the sergeant, who had an excellent record, to nine years in prison. Perhaps the reason why this judge has the same name as singer Guy Mitchell is because his brand of "justice" will have good citizens "Singing The Blues."
Another possible case of a cop being treated unfairly is NYPD Assistant Chief Benjamin Gurley. On May 24, 7:45.p.m., at a ShopRite Parking Lot in Garnerville, NY, Gurley approached a man who was allegedly harassing his daughter. He allegedly assaulted Gurley and, in a struggle, went to grab his gun. One shot was fired with nobody being hit.
As of this writing, Gurley is on modified duty while the alleged attacker and harasser has not been arrested.
Also, in the May 22 issue is "Parole officer hospitalized after drugs blown in face during Queens arrest." The arrested man was 58-year-old Adam Adams, who had served time for murder and attempted kidnapping. This once again raises the question of why are murderers paroled? It also spreads more doubt on the theory of people aging out of crime.
Also, being soft on crime is a bipartisan problem. Presenting Donald Trump as law and order is as believable as if Jesse James came back to life and ran as the "law and order" candidate. You're not tough on crime if you turn into a bleeding-heart liberal when the criminals are Trump and the insurrectionists.
Richard Warren
4 comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here
Valete
Mr. Warren’s compelling essay delves into the stark contrast between two cases involving a judge’s decision. In one case, a NYPD sergeant was sentenced to nine years in prison for throwing a water cooler at a suspect fleeing on a motorized scooter, accidentally killing the suspect. In stark contrast, a man who brutally beat a homeless man to death received a mere nine-month sentence. This imbalance of justice raises profound questions as to justice and fairness in our legal system. Having said that, I disagree with Mr. Warren’s statement: presenting Donald Trump as law and order is as believable as if Jesse James had come back to life and had run for office as the “law and order” candidate. Why? Jesse James was a cold-blooded killer; President Trump and the protesters were victims of partisan justice. Aside from that minor point, I applaud Mr. Warren’s essay; it impels one to question the disparity between justice and injustice, which frequently permeates the criminal justice system.
Wednesday, June 10 Report this
Admin
Trump must have had supporters like Word Man in mind when he said he could shoot someone on 5th Avenue and they'd still support him.
Wednesday, June 10 Report this
reenjoe
Jesse James killed 15-20 people during the Civil War and his reign of crime. Trump has killed thousands of Iranians, dozens of boaters and 3 more Indian sailors today, all in cold blood. James had nothing on Trump.
Thursday, June 11 Report this
namrogm
Word Man, DJT and the protesters were victims of partisan justice? If by “protesters” you mean the Jan 6 Insurrectionists, you’re wrong and like Trump you’re allergic to the truth. Trump and the insurrections are traitors.
Tuesday, June 16 Report this